| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • Work with all your cloud files (Drive, Dropbox, and Slack and Gmail attachments) and documents (Google Docs, Sheets, and Notion) in one place. Try Dokkio (from the makers of PBworks) for free. Now available on the web, Mac, Windows, and as a Chrome extension!

View
 

Viva Voce Examination

Page history last edited by Steve Moss 9 years, 9 months ago Saved with comment

'The viva voce examination'

 

#phdchat tweet log -11th January 2012

 

@NSRiazat - Welcome to #phdchat - the topic for tonight is 'the viva voce/defence' examination'. #phd #phdchat

@ClaretCarly - @LBA_OX12 Same here, but I have a feeling it'll come round quicker than I'd like to imagine! #phdchat

@beckyheaver - My viva is in a couple of months so definitely joining in #phdchat tonight!

@NSRiazat - @lizith - aww thank you. #phdchat wouldn't be the great resource it is without all your contributions. :)

@lizith - @NSRiazat I'm probably mainly a lurker tonight, but interested in people's experiences #phdchat

@srossmktg - @NSRiazat You mean like dissertation defense? Proposal defense? Both? #phdchat

@profology - Time for academics to withdraw free labour: http://t.co/9rwFTEwl #highered #phdchat #cdnpse

@UK_DZ_Bella - Hi every one #phdchat.

@lizgloyn - Hi #phdchat - I have survived a PhD defence in the US system, but tips on preparation apply to both US and UK way of doing things!

@UK_DZ_Bella - @beckyheaver Me too and good luck #phdchat

@lizgloyn - @srossmktg In UK, the viva voce is the equivalent of the dissertation defence - both happen when PhD has been completed #phdchat

@Janshs - @NSRiazat: Welcome to #phdchat - the topic for tonight is 'the viva voce/defence' examination'. #phd #phdchat

@lizgloyn - @srossmktg In UK, viva is done by two academics who are NOT your supervisor, as opposed to US committee who have seen work grow #phdchat

@srossmktg - @lizgloyn Ah. Interesting. Totally different cultures on that... #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @UK_DZ_Bella Thanks you too! #phdchat

@lizith - don't know if it is just me, but Twitter is very slow here this evening #phdchat

@UK_DZ_Bella - @lizgloyn an external and internal examiners will be there, also your supervisor will attend! #phdchat

@mdanganh - Summer School: "Research on computer-mediated communication in #linguistics" http://t.co/1PXKXEUT #phdchat #CMC

@srossmktg - @lizgloyn Very very true. I have to defend my proposal first. There is no final defence if that doesn't happen. #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - What is the purpose of the vive? Is it an oral exam or checking that U can justify ur thesis? #phdchat

@srossmktg - @lizgloyn In my dept, that tends to be more a formality. As does the final defence. Unless it's all fatally flawed. #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @lizith It's a bit slow for me too :-) #phdchat

@srossmktg - @lizgloyn Since our committee is supposedly moving us along on the right track, the defence is more of a gauntlet than anything. #phdchat

@lizith - @beckyheaver so I can't blame son for hogging all the bandwidth with his gaming! #phdchat

@carinavr - @LBA_OX12 Purpose of viva is partly to ensure that the thesis is your own work. #phdchat

@lizgloyn - @LBA_OX12 Viva is oral exam which is meant to make sure 1) that you did your own work 2) that you can justify your arguments ... #phdchat

@lizgloyn - @LBA_OX12 3) that you can place your work in the context of wider academic world & 4) that you deserve the doctorate, based on 1-3 #phdchat

@carinavr - @srossmktg In my experience none was a formality but a real hurdle you had to get over. In proposal defence 1 of group failed. #phdchat

@lizgloyn - @srossmktg I didn't have proposal defence, but it did have to be approved by departmental committee - I had to rewrite mine #phdchat

@srossmktg - @carinavr I hadn't seen a failure, but I did see a final defence where the question was relatively easy and it wasnt addressed well #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - ooh, #phdchat discussion is on dissertation defenses! goll, i hope we revisit this say... some time in 2015/2016, lol! *lurks*

@lizgloyn - @srossmktg Only failures at final defence in US I know of are where student was given advice and utterly ignored it #phdchat

@srossmktg - @lizgloyn Ah, see, my advisor is making me do a "miniproposal" so I don't go horribly off track before the formal one. #phdchat

@yukrla - @lizgloyn I am having to rewrite a section of my 'transfer' document too...how did you go along that? #phdchat

@lizgloyn - @srossmktg These things vary hugely from dept to dept and discipline to discipline. Sounds like your advisor has the right idea! #phdchat

@lizgloyn - @yukrla My problem was that my proposed topic was too broad, so I had to narrow it down; basically had to come up w/smaller idea #phdchat

@carinavr - @srossmktg Also not aware of failure in final viva, but do know of major revisions, for which get 18 months to complete. #phdchat

@srossmktg - @lizgloyn Totally. I know our acctg PhDs (we share office) have totally different req's for theirs. #phdchat

@yukrla - Mine is that they say I need to make more explicit an area of the literature and make my argument stand out more #phdchat @lizgloyn

@weeladybird1981 - #phdchat big thing for me is to keep calm enough that i do myself justice in the viva.need to control my nerves so my head doesn't go blank.

@LBA_OX12 - @lizgloyn Thx for the v. helpful explanation #phdchat

@srossmktg - @carinavr I've heard of pass with major or minor revisions. Rarely no revisions. Ours go to journals, so esstly starts tenure clock #phdchat

@yukrla - in my department 5 people have passed this year with no revisions....it is becoming more common #phdchat @srossmktg

@sarahthesheepu - hellos #phdchat whats the topic?

@beckyheaver - @weeladybird1981 Me too, I worry that I won't put myself across well, my mind will go blank or that they just hate it #phdchat

@lizith - @sarahthesheepu the viva #phdchat

@Janshs - @lizith twitter slow/not working? for me too #phdchat

@Janshs - I recommend 'the end is where you begin' Trafford & Leshem re viva #phdchat hope I've remembered title correctly

@carinavr - @srossmktg Have same stories. One person at my Uni in London that I know of had no revisions. #phdchat

@sarahthesheepu - @lizith i loved mine preparation is key #phdchat hope yours is going ok Liz

@weeladybird1981 - @beckyheaver yeah that's exactly how i feel :( i need to convince myself to be calm and confident! #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @sarahthesheepu @lizith What sort of preparation did you do? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @Janshs - lurking tonight as viva voce exam is something I still need to think about. #phdchat

@carinavr - @beckyheaver Thought it would be so for me also, but on morning of viva I realized that I know most of my work. Preparation key. #phdchat

@srossmktg - @carinavr Mktg scholarship (in the US) has moved to multi-essay format. Books dont help TT, so each essay fcns as a journal article #phdchat

@SteveCooke - Currently waiting for a date for my viva - looking forward to chatting about my thesis to 2 of only 4 people who've read all of it! #phdchat

@sarahthesheepu - @Janshs i really enjoyed mine ive blogged about it http://t.co/O3Uuc1tC #phdchat

@Janshs - @NSRiazat there will be lots about this on the resi w/end but maybe you could bring the archive of #phdchat?

@beckyheaver - @carinavr I feel like I can only hold little bits of it in my head at any one time #phdchat

@one_tim_martin - @beckyheaver @weeladybird1981 just need to work on building confidence... Remember your doing phd as your capable #phdchat

@sarahthesheepu - @beckyheaver @lizith i had a mock viva and worked on having a good prepared answer 2 what is thesis about & re read your work! #phdchat

@carinavr - @srossmktg ah, makes sense. Also closer to real experience of being academic, I suppose. #phdchat

@weeladybird1981 - @beckyheaver exactly - you just can't predict how 2 other people will read it & what they'll pick up on. can't wait til it's over! #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @sarahthesheepu Mock viva might help, will see if I can have one, but my supervisor has left #phdchat

@Janshs - @carinavr for sure #phdchat helped me 'learn' the thesis

@beckyheaver - @weeladybird1981 Agree and agree :-) #phdchat

@lizith - @beckyheaver ask research convenor or DocSchool #phdchat

@carinavr - @beckyheaver I also thought so. But in preparation, when people asked me questions, realized how much had internalized #phdchat

@srossmktg - @carinavr Probably more a function of books not counting for tenure in our field. Multi-essay easier than carving up a monograph. #phdchat

@profology - Up for #Tenure, Facing Depression: http://t.co/Q3gzR2rA #highered #faculty #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @lizith They won't have read it though, but I guess it would be good to practise general questions #phdchat

@weeladybird1981 - @one_tim_martin @beckyheaver yeah you're right - need to remember that. thanks. #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @carinavr Yes I do surprise myself sometimes at what I do remember when people ask, thanks #phdchat

@carinavr - @beckyheaver Also didn't have supervisor at end, but friends who completed PhDs, asked me questions, as if mock viva. #phdchat

@lizith - @beckyheaver have you colleagues that might grill you - I've got a couple of docs of nasty qns from an OU colleague #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @weeladybird1981 @one_tim_martin Yes, thanks :-) #phdchat Need to write that on a post-it

@carinavr - @beckyheaver I also googled for type of questions asked; many blog postings that very helpful. #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @carinavr Ok, mock viva def seems to be way to go, then it wont' be so bad the second time #phdchat

@beckyheaver - @lizith Would you be willing to forward them to me? #phdchat

@lizith - while folk are around, please look at http://t.co/LB2dGBQR & nominate @NSRiazat for in recognition for all she has done for us #phdchat

@lizith - @beckyheaver will do - your sussex address I assume? #phdchat

@carinavr - Friend reminded me before viva that I am only person to have done my specific research. It was MY research. Gave me confidence. #phdchat

@evalantsoght - I nominate @NSRiazat for a Shorty Award in #education because of her dedication to the #phdchat community http://t.co/RDuelC1E

@beckyheaver - @lizith Yes please! Thanks :-) #phdchat

@carinavr - Viva was wonderful experience. 2 people took time to read every word I wrote & then engaged me on those for 3 hours - how amazing #phdchat

@beckyheaver - I have to sign off now, but thanks everybody! #phdchat

@yukrla - #phdchat Very nice session, thank you @NSRiazat once more. Bye for now!

@aeratcliffe - Just arrived and caught up on the tweets. My viva is a ways off, but good to start thinking of it now. I like the idea of a mock. #phdchat

@christiepooh - @srossmktg @lizgloyn I am that same: defend proposal, no final. Thank goodness! #phdchat

@lizith - @NSRiazat thanks for organising as ever #phdchat

@christiepooh - Since my defend is after committee approval of proposal, I wonder if it is mostly formal or a real oral test? Now I wonder! #phdchat

@rob_dphillips - Good day #phdchat supervisor chat :-)

@eLizHartnett - Preparing for my viva last March-May, I used Rowena Murray's book http://t.co/EkMrFbbB #phdChat as well as those nasty OU questions @lizith

@JackieKirkham - sorry to miss #phdchat re viva. Enjoyed mine (thx to @KateT_health who was external!). Prepare, relax, don't have a watch! Reread b4 helped.

@EmmaBurnettx - @NSRiazat sorry I missed #phdchat this evening. For a nice change I was totally engrossed in writing & didn't realise time!

@JackieKirkham - @eLizHartnett @lizith yes me too, helpful book even tho just skimmed it #phdchat

@mark_carrigan - Is it a bad idea to self-publish an academic book? People keep telling me it is but I think this won't be accepted til people do it #phdchat

@qui_oui - So many of my ideas are in my notebooks. I've decided to digitise those and put them with my other dissertation materials. #PhDchat

@elebelfiore - @mark_carrigan This is true. It all depends on whether you are prepared to pay the price any pioneer has to pay #phdchat

@sarahthesheepu - problem with #phdchat on vivas is most of the postdocs dont seem to be about tonight we need to do #askapostdoc questions

@NSRiazat - @salma_patel @PhDViva - thanks for the link Salma - have RT'd to #phdchat

@openinformation - very nice @mdanganh: Summer School: "Research on computer-mediated communication in #linguistics" http://t.co/2hAObqTR #phdchat #CMC

@sarahthesheepu - @DrHG no not at all! anyone got any viva questions still now there are 2 of us here? #phdchat

@linguisticsbonn - @mdanganh: Summer School: "Research on computer-mediated communication in #linguistics" http://t.co/oEmiIuj3 #phdchat #CMC

@EmmaBurnettx - A must read: A personal experience of successfully surviving (and enjoying!) your #phd Viva by @sarahthesheepu #phdchat http://t.co/jKJjMrKF

@AmandaMichelle - "@sarahthesheepu: problem with #phdchat on vivas is most of the postdocs dont seem to be about tonight we need to do #askapostdoc questions

@AmandaMichelle - @sarahthesheepu i have SO MANY postdoc questions! #phdchat

@DrHG - @AmandaMichelle @sarahthesheepu I am happy to answer any postdoc questions you have #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @janshs - reading an academic researcher's interpretation of how to 'mould and manoeuvre' organisational culture. Not convinced... #phdchat

@152Sm - working on chemical reagents and doing computation on them, Can any one suggest me a comprehensive handout/book for Gaussian? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @janshs - but also come across a great conceptual model for organisational culture earlier so a productive evening of reading. #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - YAYAY!!! #phdchat RULZ! RT @sarahthesheepu: @DrHG @me ooh we have http://t.co/kMpD6bcP now a wiki for post docs

@KateT_health - @JackieKirkham aww I enjoyed your viva too. My first time on that side of the table. My own was almost disappointingly friendly .. #phdchat

@k10death - @qui_oui i'm finally reading the long-ago bookmarked posts you wrote on mental health & phd studies. great work. #phdchat

@daciatakesnote - I nominate @nsriazat for a Shorty Award in #education b/c of her hard work and dedication to #phdchat http://t.co/Mxp8WSRb

@TwtrChat411 - #PhDchat starts at 7:30pm GMT moderated by @NSRiazat Participate!

@LSEImpactBlog - Podcasts, presentations, and how-to guides on writing abstracts and more #academia #phdchat #blogging http://t.co/TdrBeoFa

@ai1sa - oh i worked right throgh #phdchat not a problem- my phd has no viva at the end. Had a colloquium 1/3rd of way in instead

@ai1sa - happens after lit rev & method organised tentatively written & with ethics thought through, but b4 data collect Australia. Not NZ #phdchat

@KingTawhiao - #Audio #Annotation of Freedmand & Holmes *The #Teacher's #Body": http://t.co/1UBVjzLB #phdchat

@cheeflo - "Hit send. Hit publish." A piece on #writing for a living. http://t.co/fADWu5u7 applicable to #phdchat (via @digitalpromises)

@ianrobsons - @MrsRF realised that how we *actually* talk is messy and multi tracked!! #phdchat #transcription

@JackieKirkham - @DrHG @AmandaMichelle @sarahthesheepu me too! #phdchat suspect viva will be an ongoing conversation point!

@KingTawhiao - #Audio #annotation in which I briefly address Orson Scott Card on #slampoetry: http://t.co/LilOIqoS #phdchat

@JackieKirkham - on a lighter note, one for the #phdchat crowd: how to read an academic article http://t.co/C2ZV96sl

@laurapasquini - What Does It Mean To Be an Academic? - http://t.co/gX6jnWPz #phdchat

@thesiswhisperer - Good one @researchwhisper! RT #shutupandwrite googlemap ready for additions http://t.co/9yjyxz14 #phdchat

@Helen_otuk - I can do this. . .RT @JackieKirkham on a lighter note, one for the #phdchat crowd: how to read an academic article http://t.co/iL1F0YqE

@profragsdale - I just got a PhD timeline 4 my last semester at Rice -- that is an intimidating timeline! #phdchat

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.