| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • Work with all your cloud files (Drive, Dropbox, and Slack and Gmail attachments) and documents (Google Docs, Sheets, and Notion) in one place. Try Dokkio (from the makers of PBworks) for free. Now available on the web, Mac, Windows, and as a Chrome extension!

View
 

The Literature Review 2

Page history last edited by Steve Moss 9 years, 9 months ago Saved with comment

'The Literature Review'

 

#phdchat tweet log - 22nd February 2012

 

@NSRiazat - Welcome to #phdchat - topic tonight is 'the literature review'. Please use the hashtag so your tweets are included in the wiki archive. :)

@NSRiazat - The key to a good literature review is knowing the purpose of it - a historical background to the research, an overview of (1/3) #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - Much reading @ this early stage- can't see the focus yet. Trying 2 work out when 2 start writing. Anyone else like this? #phdchat #phdchat

@NSRiazat - ...the current context, a discussion of theories/concepts underpinning research and relevant terminology and definitions... (2/3) #phdchat

@NSRiazat - ...to show how the terminology will be used in context of own research....(3/3). Wish I had known this beforehand! :-) #phdchat

@planetchampion - I called my Lit Rev The Engine when writing. It drives the research + justifies gap -without it there is no PhD No uniqueness #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @LBA_OX12 - was in the same place in the early stages of PhD. It becomes clearer as the work evolves over time. #phdchat

@CET47 - @LBA_OX12 I was like that at the beginning as well. im now a year into my PhD and everything is much better. #phdchat

@RichJ23 - @NSRiazat I spent a while just reading papers without a sense of direction. Focus one of the most important aspects of research #phdchat

@planetchampion - You can put terminology into a glossary. Don't bore your examiner! Lit Rev tells a strong story Why What's gone before. Why Unique #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @LBA_OX12 ~ whatever read in the early stages and not used in the thesis can be saved for other papers, articles and blogs. #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - @NSRiazat Thx. It's as clear as mud @ present #phdchat #phdchat

@respros - @LBA_OX12 Enjoy and embrace the chaos I say. I was like that for at least a year before things started to settle down. #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @RichJ23 ~ yes agree. Did the same in early stages. Now reading is more focused and targetted but it does take time to get there. #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - my question on the lit review side of things: HOW do u know when enough is enough & what to in-/exclude esp in terms of objectivity #phdchat

@planetchampion - @respros @LBA_OX12 If you want to do it in 3 years You can't be confused for 12 months #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @LBA_OX12 - hang in there - it does become clearer as you progress through the months. #phdchat

@RichJ23 - @NSRiazat took me 4 months until I really had a problem to get my teeth stuck into - then lit search became interesting. #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - i'm over here trynna participate in #phdchat like i'm not at internship needing to do work. O_o

@LBA_OX12 - Thx for replies - I've the broad problem - can't narrow it down yet..... #phdchat #phdchat

@planetchampion - @NSRiazat Not unusual!!! Having a strong sense on the contribution makes a whole lot of things easier! :-) #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - @planetchampion Doing it part-time - started Oct' 11 - #phdchat #phdchat

@ClaretCarly - @RichJ23 @nsriazat I worry about the extent of my literature search & missing papers out. I guess the question is when to stop? #phdchat

@planetchampion - @LBA_OX12 Part-time is really hard! but I did mine around 3 kids as single parent. To do a PhD you have to know your U contribution #phdchat

@planetchampion - @ClaretCarly @RichJ23 @nsriazat Knowing when to stop! That was a question I was asked at my pre-phd interview! any ideas? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @planetchampion @LBA_OX12 ~ agreed - contribution to new knowledge/analysis is the difference between a PhD and a Masters degree. #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @planetchampion @ClaretCarly @RichJ23 - stopped when same/similar ideas came out in papers/books I was reading. #phdchat

@martin_eve - Copyright and academia; particularly for Ph.Ds http://t.co/aS74w4lK #Copyright #PhDchat #Sussex

@NSRiazat - @planetchampion @ClaretCarly @RichJ23 ~ think you just have to make a conscious decision to stop - it's an endless task otherwise. #phdchat

@planetchampion - @NSRiazat @ClaretCarly @RichJ23 AND Crucially when the same AUTHORS keep reappearing -do you know your audience? #phdchat

@CET47 - I'm afraid of missing something really important in my lit review! its not possible to read absolutely everything! #phdchat

@ClaretCarly - @NSRiazat @planetchampion @richj23 True, there is only so much time! #phdchat

@planetchampion - Also have to keep an eye on the lit throughout -an examiner will look at submission date and refs v carefully! #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Anyone used http://t.co/1P3NFwpS (Consortium of University research Libraries - COPAC) as a resource? #phdchat

@planetchampion - @CET47 Very understandable -it's why Authors are the key -you can search for their new work more easily -check their refs etc #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - #phdchat Hi Just catching up on tonight's chat - been doing kids pick ups!

@ai1sa - several layers to litR: the question, gaps to explore, method to use, how informs analysis, & conclusions= Very iterative process #phdchat

@martin_eve - Apologies, that copyright link was borked. #phdchat

@planetchampion - First thing the examiner will look at will be the refs section Make sure it is PERFECT and you have read everything in it! #phdchat

@martin_eve - Copyright and academia; particularly for Ph.Ds. Fixed link! http://t.co/k9ZaeclD #phdchat

@NSRiazat - #phdchat - http://t.co/BlFyTfrb - also worth a look but is not up to date. Still some useful sources. #phdchat

@planetchampion - @ai1sa That sounds like a description of a year 1 report to me -not a lit rev for a thesis? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Extracting and synthesising the main points, issues, findings to the strict word limit is a challenge at times. #phdchat

@CET47 - @ai1sa @planetchampion I agree i think that sounds very like what I had to put together to transfer to 2nd year. #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @planetchampion @ai1sa Lit rev can include several discourses, though? Sometimes I have a hard time keeping mine separate! #phdchat

@planetchampion - @NSRiazat ALWAYS worry about the word limit AFTER you have got the story right.... #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Also used Excel mindmaps to make links between papers and academics from literature review reading to make it flow better. #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - How about defining a puzzle, anyone else had troubles with that? I find it really difficult! #phdchat

@ClaretCarly - @RichJ23 @nsriazat @LBA_OX12 My supervisor suggested I write a review paper in 1st yr, really helped to focus my reading #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @planetchampion - wrote 'freestyle' in Yr 1/2 and now cutting & editing the most useful and relevant sections now I have more data #phdchat

@planetchampion - @LottaFriedner @ai1sa Discourses on method + analysis in a methods chap will keep clarity in your writing #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @NSRiazat That's a nice idea, I'll try that! #phdchat

@Janshs - What's #PhDChat topic?

@planetchampion - @LottaFriedner @ai1sa You need to be crystal clear on your unique contribution which isn't usually a new method? #phdchat

@planetchampion - @NSRiazat When do you think you will finish? #phdchat

@planetchampion - @ClaretCarly @RichJ23 @nsriazat @LBA_OX12 You should read and then write; read and then write etc all the way through! #phdchat

@RichJ23 - @NSRiazat @planetchampion @claretcarly ... I found it very useful to start with papers which themselves are a review. #phdchat

@ai1sa - @LottaFriedner yes, lit review for me separated the discourses so i could locate gaps- which was tied heavilly to a method of study #phdchat

@planetchampion - @ai1sa @LottaFriedner That sounds excellent! Getting logical coherence all the way through is a huge challenge! :-) #phdchat

@ai1sa - more than one way to skin a cat or to use literature in a phd #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - I agree not much being said about pro bill - cos there is no pro bill! #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @Janshs ~ the literature review #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @ai1sa How was that tied to the method? My discourses are separated by topics and ontological premises more than by methods. #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - sorry wrong chat - jumping between nhssm debate #phdchat

@planetchampion - @ai1sa RE:more than one way to skin a cat or to use literature in a phd But only a few if you want to do it in 3 years #phdchat

@ai1sa - @LottaFriedner am studying change, & my methodology actor-network theory is a 'theory' of translation/change, so addresses the gap #phdchat

@Janshs - @NSRiazat ok sounds good #PhDChat

@ai1sa - @planetchampion I am in my eigth year PT. A longterm study of change and use of emergent technology. #phdchat

@ai1sa - some fields (mine) the literature was not present at the start of the field, so it is not a linear process #phdchat

@planetchampion - @ai1sa Ailsa I'd be interested to know which 'emergent tec' you've been following #phdchat

@ai1sa - @planetchampion use of SMS messaging for counselling #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @ai1sa Yes, I know my area, theory and empirics, I want to contribute to more knowledge about it but hard to force it into a puzzle #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @germankiwi Right! But I start from a theory, can't study empirics before I have defined the problem... #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - Ggap in lit in my area, so trying to mine lit to see what's around & impinging #phdchat #phdchat

@ai1sa - @LottaFriedner ahh: deciding on thesis direction from post doc directions=overwhelm the small space=just one part of the puzzle #phdchat

@EnricoCoiera - New BMJ blog summarises my experience so far with twitter for research #hcsm #originoftheses #phdchat http://t.co/iJoIHsjm

@germankiwi - @LottaFriedner Mhm. Maybe there is a Puzzle in the theory? maybe be in form of a oaradoxon? #phdchat

@germankiwi - @LottaFriedner Paradoxon i meant of course #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - @LottaFriedner So how have you defined or come up with a puzzle? #phdchat #phdchat

@ai1sa - @LottaFriedner i invested most of 2011 re-tailoring my literature sections to suit the findings i have space for in the phd #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @germankiwi oaradoxon? A paradox? That's what I'm after! :) Need to do lit rev to find it, though! #phdchat

@ai1sa - my recalcitrant lit review helped hugely by the ch putting the octopus in the jar in Kamler and Thompsons http://t.co/nhkcn52X #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @ai1sa I have already changed the topic quite dramatically when I couldn't locate a good q - so have also read a lot I won't use #phdchat

@NSRiazat - 8.30pm brings us to the end of tonight's live #phdchat session - many thanks for valued contributions/following tonight :) #phdchat #phd

@ai1sa - @LottaFriedner i describe how my q morphed over time #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @NSRiazat Thank you! #phdchat

@ai1sa - @LottaFriedner i dont think there's ever anyone who doesnt read far more than will ever see light of day in the thesis :) #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @ai1sa Haha, you're right! That way at least we'll be able to engage with people in different areas! #phdchat

@salma_patel - @ai1sa Thanks, feel free to add it on :-) (Not sure I've got an account there any more) #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @ai1sa Probably a good strategy? I guess you always get to a pt where you have thematerial and just have to choose how to frame it. #phdchat

@lizith - @salma_patel @ai1sa if you mean the #phdchat wiki - your registration doesn't lapse :)

@ai1sa - @LottaFriedner was once told the good phder is the one who knows what to leave out #phdchat

@bennosaurus - Twitter, is there a contemporary counterpart to Kate Millet's Sexual Politics? #phdchat

@salma_patel - @lizith @ai1sa Pleased to hear ;-) #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @germankiwi I am convinced it is. Just afraid not to find it... But I guess that's the nature of it! :) #phdchat

@germankiwi - @LottaFriedner I guess so too. Took me a while to find my puzzle :) And maybe you find a different one while doing the lit review #phdchat

@LottaFriedner - @LBA_OX12 Still working on it! Reality doesn't fit with theory I use, so that's one pzl, but there are other possible theories... #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - @germankiwi @LottaFriedner Yes, I have the puzzle, can't see the pieces yet... #phdchat #phdchat

@diana_whalen - Busy working on a symposium submission for ABCT 2012 #phdchat #acwri

@imakec02 - Totally off topic (apolog) - but I'm doing a research presentation tomorrow. Any tips for how many images / slides lasting 20 mins? #phdchat

@CET47 - @imakec02 probably about 15 slides for 20 mins, not too much text on the slides and only relevant images eg graphs,tables, maps #phdchat

@ScholarAtLarge - @imakec02 about 17 slides (a bit more than a min to talk about each) (for a 15 min presentation i usually have 12 slides) #phdchat

@srossmktg - TWO HOUR meeting with my advisor. Feel good about the direction of my thesis, but my head's definitely spinning. #phdchat

@David_S_Bristol - On the subject of PhDs - RT @martin_eve: Copyright and academia; particularly for Ph.Ds. Fixed link! http://t.co/Wu42MfHP #phdchat

@David_S_Bristol - Commented incl. qu: Does University hosting prevent publication?RT @martin_eve: Copyright and academia http://t.co/Wu42MfHP #phdchat

@SchulichENGG - Why you should be following the hashtags #MyResearch and #PhDChat > #Engineering + #Science community talks Twitter, http://t.co/zpoEiELv

@strictlykaren - @srossmktg how frequently do you meet with sups? Are you full or part time #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Just reflecting on what a valuable supportive resource #phdchat has become over the year: a resource for PhD students by PhD students. #phd

@NSRiazat - Would like to sincerely thank all PhD students who post on #phdchat for making it such a great resource throughout my studies. #phd

@NSRiazat - @LottaFriedner - mind mapping really helped to see the key themes/arguments and what they meant to my research context emerging. #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @ClaretCarly @RichJ23 @LBA_OX12 - like the idea of a review paper to help focus the teading. :) #phdchat

@savasavasava - @NSRiazat it's been a while! I need to jump into one of the #phdchat meetings soon. I miss them. and I need them!

@NSRiazat - @ClaretCarly @RichJ23 - I also worry about missing a key paper or argument out. Just know I will find day before I submit. :-) #phdchat

@Janshs - @NSRiazat @claretcarly @richj23 probably the day after :)) #PhDChat

@ClaretCarly - @NSRiazat @richj23 @lba_ox12 It certainly helped with early reading & writing, and I'm now close to getting it published #phdchat

@NSRiazat - "@Janshs: @NSRiazat @claretcarly @richj23 probably the day after :)) #PhDChat" (LOL - will happen for sure now hehe.) :)))

@NSRiazat - @savasavasava - please do join us for #phdchat always great to catch up/hear from everyone - will be posting a poll in few days :) #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @ClaretCarly @richj23 @lba_ox12 - Excellent - a brilliant idea for focusing reading early on. I did 'laundry list' initially. :) #phdchat

@ClaretCarly - @NSRiazat @richj23 @lba_ox12 Yes, I'm extremely grateful to my supervisor for the suggestion! #phdchat

@indianscribes - 3 steps to better qualitative research design http://t.co/wIK9z9Va #phdchat via @streamresearch

@XarahC - @NSRiazat trying to catch up on chat: it's amazing how you instinctively develop a sense of focus for lit over a cpl years #phdchat

@PleagleTrainer - Making espresso, bacon and eggs. Imagining Bruno Latour and Pierre Bourdieu engaged in arm wrestling #phdchat #legaled #fb

@NSRiazat - "@Vitae_news Prof Matt Lambon Ralph Uni of Manchester - speaker at #Vitae12 Doctoral Training Centres http://t.co/hXJZf2kX @Uomnews #phdchat

@XarahC - @thesiswhisperer I've made a concerted effort to find the bulk of my literature from open-source channels- less demand less supply! #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @XarahC - agree - developing a literature focus does take time, experimenting with and exploring concepts over first few years. #phdchat

@srossmktg - @strictlykaren Were not doing "by committee" so much as one-on-one with advisor, thenmembers as needed. And Im meeting 3x/wk (FT). #phdchat

@rjfmelis - "@EnricoCoiera: New BMJ blog: my experience with twitter for research #hcsm #originoftheses #phdchat http://t.co/Uq04lDnl" Very nice! Thnx

@EvaAlisic - Wohooo, made my first Instruction Video! Twitter for Academics interested in trauma/mental health: http://t.co/hKscxswr #phdchat #hcsmanz

@EvaAlisic - Twitter for Academics: Instruction Video http://t.co/hKscxswr To share with not-yet-tweeters (via email) #phdchat #phd #research

@NSRiazat - @EvaAlisic - thanks for this link Eva - looks like a great resource. :) #phdchat #phd #research

@zaana - #phd 18month review submitted! & on time! w00t! 30K words, 100pgs w appendices. :D #phdchat #cultofdone #phew

@srossmktg - @zaana 18 month review? That's 3/8 of my program... #phdchat

@laramcpherson - @zaana Kicking goals Zaana! Amazing work! #phd #phdchat #cultofdone #phew

@thesiswhisperer - The academic writers strike - should you sign the cost of knowledge petition? The Thesis Whisperer http://t.co/wHZ7kQAh #phdchat

@ai1sa - I <3 my local librarian Andrew rocks! Hav migrated ENX3 to ENx4 with no tears, all files intact, Just a compressed file, all sweet #phdchat

@ai1sa - @PleagleTrainer who won the latour-bordieu arm wrestling? My money is on Latour. #phdchat

@effectsofNAPLAN - Great post about the thievery of written research @thesiswhisperer: http://t.co/QCUmzIh8 #phdchat #highered

@DaleReardon - What you should do with a paper once it has been published http://t.co/PJX4O0pU #phdchat #highered

@DaleReardon - Thought provoking RT @thesiswhisperer: The academic writers strike - should you sign the petition? http://t.co/ZUN15Y0n #phdchat

@PhillyPhutnotes - Me: Why do you have your sunglasses on in class? / / Student: Because the sun never sets in the land of cool. #phdchat #college

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.