| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • You already know Dokkio is an AI-powered assistant to organize & manage your digital files & messages. Very soon, Dokkio will support Outlook as well as One Drive. Check it out today!

View
 

Publishing your Work

Page history last edited by Steve Moss 11 years, 11 months ago Saved with comment

'Publishing your work: What are journals looking for'

 

#phdchat tweet log - 4th July 2012

 

@NSRiazat - Welcome to #phdchat - the topic for tonight is 'publishing your work: what are journals looking for'. #PhD

@ianrobsons - 3 out of 4 children in bed. Cup of tea drunk. Can I pull it together to finish this note on my narrative analysis? [slumps] #phdchat

@srossmktg - Oh wow. With the holiday, I forgot it was #phdchat time... #phdchat

@yimeizhu - I would love to know what journals looking for. as PhD student, I find this is what we need to learn urgently! #phdchat

@Donna_Peach - I'm a novice but I guess they are looking for research which makes a new contribution to knowledge #phdchat

@srossmktg - Journals? Looking for one thing, *really* looking for another. #phdchat

@Donna_Peach - I think its important that the methodology is sound and can sustain rigorous examination #phdchat

@AndrologistUK - #phdchat journals normally publish their scope in their information for authors.

@NSRiazat - @Comprof1 ~ look forward to catching up with you on tonight's #phdchat a little later on. :-)

@NSRiazat - Recognising realistic opportunities to be able to publish work is a good starting point...but how to choose...? #phdchat #publishing.

@aeratcliffe - I wish I could join #phdchat today, but I have a deadline for tomorrow evening. Hello to all.

@NSRiazat - In order to get my own work 'out there' and beyond supervisor audience is to dessiminate it via publishing either journals/blogs #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Anyone familiar with that saying....'publish or perish....?' #phdchat #PhD

@savasavasava - @NSRiazat running out to 4th of July BBQ, but wanted to say hi to #phdchat <3

@DrSustainable - Yes. Not helpful. Creates fear which leads to poor papers..@NSRiazat: Anyone familiar with that saying.'publish or perish?' #phdchat #PhD

@sakinasofia - Some say dont go for high impact journals as we are newbies.. so journal selection is important #phdchat

@merry30 - Hurrah! Have actually made it home and to sofa in time for (most of) #phdchat !!

@AndrologistUK - "@NSRiazat: Anyone familiar with that saying....'publish or perish....?' #phdchat #PhD" I had an idea that was for academic staff!

@Donna_Peach - @NSRiazat Although I think peer review is important, I applaud the moves to enable increased dissemination of good research #phdchat

@merry30 - @sakinasofia But (if you're in the UK) (and if you want an academic career) at least one high impact pub is very valuable #phdchat

@yimeizhu - instread of thinking what the journals are looking for? have you thought about what we are looking for in a journal? #openaccess #phdchat

@bevgibbs - @sakinasofia Hiya-Whats the rationale for avoiding high impact journals? #phdchat

@AndrologistUK - How do you find the submitting process @NSRiazat ? Do you have many rejections? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @merry30 ~ a publication is more important when faced with job interviews and PhD people who have published. #phdchat

@lizith - @bevgibbs @sakinasofia I think it is find the right journal, rather than avoid high impact #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @savasavasava @aeratcliffe ~ have a great evening at BBQ and meeting deadlines. Am catching up with work emails. #phdchat

@srossmktg - In our field, thesis time is best time to shoot for top journals as most eyes are on it before submission. #phdchat

@yimeizhu - if the journal is open access or allow u self-archive in OA repository, will it increase readership,thus citation? #openaccess #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @DrSustainable ~ haven't been pressured to publish. Am aiming to publish once thesis has been written and submitted. #phdchat

@aeratcliffe - @NSRiazat @savasava Thanks. Would prefer to be going to the BBQ :) #phdchat

@merry30 - @NSRiazat Yes. That's what I said, I think! What I meant, anyway... Even early career job adverts are asking for "REFable" #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @AndrologistUK ~ submitting once thesis has been finished ~ know that getting thesis into an article will be challenge. #phdchat

@Katherine_McDon - @NSRiazat Conference proceedings can be a good way to go. #phdchat #publishing

@ianrobsons - https://t.co/CUGgzKos < what my brain is working with tonight #analysis #phdchat #narrative

@NSRiazat - @AndrologistUK ~ challenge when turning a thesis into a journal article and writing succintly and still within a proprt context #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - yup, i managed to forget all about #phdchat

@sakinasofia - @lizith @bevgibbs agree but with REF & all...HEIs & jobs looks at impact factor ;( #phdchat

@AndrologistUK - I think a thesis could yield several papers, I know mine will. #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Do people think that the journal article shoud follow/contribute to the wider 'conversation' of fellow publishers? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @AndrologistUK ~ mine will result in a number of papers possibly too. #phdchat

@lindalevitt - @Katherine_McDon @NSRiazat Also book reviews and online peer reviewed journals for short pieces if appropriate to your field #phdchat

@srossmktg - @NSRiazat Our field's norm is multi-essay format; much easier to submit to journals. @AndrologistUK #phdchat

@lizith - @NSRiazat @andrologistuk For conferences, I tend to focus on aspects not for thesis & am working on a couple of draft articles #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Can anyone suggest any things that they feel should be avoided when writing for journals eg being over ambitious, unanalytical etc #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Publishing is also an outlet for all the writing which was not included in the final thesis #phdchat

@lizith - @sakinasofia because I want to get findings out there, but not all findings will go in thesis and post-thesis publications #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - Ah! RT @jlwestwood: RT @NSRiazat: Welcome to #phdchat - the topic for tonight is 'publishing your work: what are journals looking for'. #PhD

@merry30 - @NSRiazat I think (as someone said earlier) that a strong well defined methodology is important. Have seem some very woolly stuff! #phdchat

@lizith - We have a session for PGRs at my uni with a rep from one of the big publishers to talk on this subject - should be interesting #phdchat

@sakinasofia - @NSRiazat yes, there are data that I can use that I did not in the thesis..am publishing a book chapter due to that #phdchat

@sakinasofia - @lizith ok so conference for non-thesis stuff & journals for thesis stuff? #phdchat

@AndrologistUK - Interesting case studies are a good excuse for essay type papers @NSRiazat @srossmktg. Wish I had time... after my thesis! #phdchat

@merry30 - @lizith That's a good idea - not sure we have that, but would be useful. ::plotting:: #phdchat

@lizith - It's worth looking for special editions of likely journals - my only article so far was very much a punt - but it worked! #phdchat

@dratarrant - @bevgibbs @sakinasofia I think it's best too aim high! Get in, great, don't, get good feedback and go to next choice after rewrite #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - My program requires us to submit at least one publication in order to advance to candidacy! #phdchat

@lizith - @sakinasofia at the moment because I want to keep my powder dry & confs are good way of testing water #phdchat

@dratarrant - @merry30 @nsriazat I'm finding it hard to write my methodology in different ways for different papers! #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - But they will allow us to do a multi-paper thesis, so long as all the papers are tied together well. #phdchat

@dratarrant - @AmandaMichelle wow that's high pressure! #phdchat

@sakinasofia - @lizith like this idea...going for it too #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - Oh, and any papers used for the dissertation have to be post-candidacy. We're not allowed to research for dissertation prior to. #phdchat

@dratarrant - @AmandaMichelle tricky in social sciences when ideas progress and change throughout #phdchat

@sakinasofia - Tips on publishing http://t.co/EhJi3Tvo #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Carefully studying the journal 'house style' also useful. #phdchat

@merry30 - Where do people stand on research student journals? Obv good experience, but where do they stand on "impact" etc? #phdchat

@srossmktg - @merry30 What's a research student journal? #phdchat

@srossmktg - Actually reading the journal helps to know style, content, methods used, types of contributions, etc. #phdchat

@sakinasofia - @NSRiazat I was advised to also quote from the journal itself #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - @AmandaMichelle I think that's the difficult aspect of the multi-paper thesis, cohesive. Finding that tight thread to bind is hard! #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - @dratarrant yes it is! I just finished my 1st year & worried about meeting that. #phdchat

@srossmktg - @londonaesthetik Nah, it's easy, conceptualize the whole thesis, then break it down into chunks. @amandamichelle #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - I've only just started working on a paper... It's pretty much done barring the formatting stuff. but it was from a chapter #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - Important!!! RT @srossmktg: Actually reading the journal helps to know style, content, methods used, types of contributions, etc. #phdchat

@merry30 - @srossmktg A journal just for research students to publish in - master's & PhD #phdchat

@Vic_McC - The I-just-bought-books-not-relating-to-my-phd guilt. #PhdChat

@dratarrant - @srossmktg @londonaesthetik @amandamichelle haha, that took me 3.5yrs....writing the thesis!! #phdchat

@srossmktg - Just got a publication in a good journal. 4 years to publication. #phdchat

@srossmktg - @merry30 British thing? #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - @londonaesthetik I don't see how people do it! Unless the have some masterplan in advance. I'm not planning that at all, lol! #phdchat

@srossmktg - @dratarrant We've got about 2. (Ive got about 1.5.) @londonaesthetik @amandamichelle #phdchat

@mitchellfriedmn - @NSRiazat Being too long...clarify appropriate length of submissions #phdchat

@AndrologistUK - I'm starting with a literature review from a slightly different angle than others have done. Doesn't need ethics approval! #phdchat

@merry30 - @srossmktg Don't know - maybe? I didn't think so but perhaps it is. #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - yes! I am having issues with that! RT @mitchellfriedmn: @NSRiazat Being too long...clarify appropriate length of submissions #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - @srossmktg @merry30 actually, I've heard of a student journal here in the US. Can't remember what it was, though. Couldn't cite. #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - Not that I know of. RT @merry30: @srossmktg Dont know - maybe? I didnt think so but perhaps it is. #phdchat

@merry30 - @AmandaMichelle @srossmktg I know - I can't remember a UK one either. Will check Delicious... #phdchat

@mitchellfriedmn - @londonaesthetik @nsriazat Currently editing a piece that has been accepted :) #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - Nice work! I need to submit!! RT @mitchellfriedmn: @londonaesthetik @nsriazat Currently editing a piece that has been accepted :) #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - #phdchat have a mental block when it comes to publishing - taking mine to conference as a poster to start

@AmandaMichelle - Anybody have issues w/ having to adjust a paper for submission? I'm thinking citations, style, and focus. #phdchat

@lizith - @merry30 @amandamichelle @srossmktg We've got one at Sussex - Excursions - http://t.co/xBE68O1A #phdchat

@merry30 - @AmandaMichelle @srossmktg There's the Library Student Journal (started at Uni of Buffalo). Obv library science only. #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - I'm also unclear on the presentation vs. journal differences. #phdchat

@srossmktg - @AmandaMichelle Just have to do it. #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - @AmandaMichelle I do, its really annoying me having to re-format everything. I save it for the real downtime, as its tedious #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - I'm involved in the start-up of a journal at Bournemouth University for grad students. #phdchat

@merry30 - @lizith @amandamichelle @srossmktg That looks really interesting - lucky you! #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - @lizith @merry30 @amandamichelle @srossmktg oh how nifty! I think the one I saw had something to do w/ social sciences. #phdchat

@LBA_OX12 - At what stage in PhD should U start 2 think about writing papers? #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - Oh wow! Just found a whole list of student journals! http://t.co/9o5Jln2f #phdchat

@srossmktg - @LBA_OX12 All of them. Always looking toward tenure... #phdchat

@lizith - @londonaesthetik I think student journals are growing in popularity - good op to see all sides of journal prod'n and get published #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - This looks awesome! RT @lizith: @merry30 amandamichelle @srossmktg We've got one at Sussex - Excursions - http://t.co/AAQHujPH #phdchat

@lizith - @LBA_OX12 As soon as you have something to say #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - #phdchat thought of publication scares me!

@TurnipRail - Well looking at the chapter with 'editing' pen marks all over it, I have decided it would just be better to sleep... #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - @londonaesthetik that sounds like a good approach. I just worry about this elusive thing called downtime, lol. #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - At the moment I've not been able to get to any of the meetings due to research travel commitments, but am on for editing once up! #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - From day 1 RT @LBA_OX12: At what stage in PhD should U start 2 think about writing papers? #phdchat

@rossguastar - #phdchat explain a poster presentation, I am not sure what that is.

@londonaesthetik - @AmandaMichelle I'm not familiar with such a word... "downtime"? What dictionary is that in? #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - yes, im behind! RT @AmandaMichelle: From day 1 RT @LBA_OX12: At what stage in PhD should U start 2 think about writing papers? #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - <~ #also. But i have no choice, if i want to graduate, lol! RT @Judiebbrell: #phdchat thought of publication scares me!

@ICTwitz - NNNNNOOOOOOOOO Just come on twitter and realised Ive missed #phdchat Gutted :-(

@AmandaMichelle - visual, static presentation w/ you on hand to answer ?s RT @rossguastar: #phdchat explain a poster presentation, I am not sure what that is.

@lizith - @ICTwitz there are a couple of minutes left and you can always catch up by looking in archive on the wiki #phdchat

@NSRiazat - 8.30pm brings us to end of #phdchat for this week - many thanks as always to all for valued contributions - have a great week everyone. :-)

@EmmaBurnettx - So I missed #wimbledon and #phdchat tonight. That's not nice

@AndrologistUK - Husband says can we do #whatshallwehavefordinnerchat, nice meeting you all, hope to contribute more next time #phdchat

@AmandaMichelle - @londonaesthetik LOL, exactly! #phdchat

@lizith - @EmmaBurnettx to miss one is excusable, but both!!! Next you'll tell us you missed tour de France too :) #phdchat

@merry30 - @NSRiazat Thank you! #phdchat

@s_holloway - @LBA_OX12 As soon as you have a chapter? #phdchat

@ICTwitz - @lizith I know, thank you :-( I like to get involved. I need to organise myself better. #phdchat

@lizith - MT @AmandaMichelle: visual, static presentation w/ you on hand to answer ? >>> great explanation of poster presentation! #phdchat

@EmmaBurnettx - @lizith ha ha! That would just tip me over the edge! :) #phdchat

@lizith - Right taking rest of evening off - conf prep can wait for tomorrow :) #phdchat

@DrSustainable - @TGJBrock @nsriazat Some institutions introducing quotas - 4 paper per year etc.. #phdchat

@DrSustainable - @NSRiazat Publishing during PhD is good if you can manage itdemonstrates impact and contribution to knowledge #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - @AmandaMichelle #phdchat luckily not the case for me! or would fail

@moorejh - MT @gawbul @qui_oui #PhD101: Build academic net; use online tools, go to confs, +keep in touch with people you meet. Don't be shy! #PhDchat

@gawbul - @AmandaMichelle @LBA_OX12 I was fortunate enough to get a paper published in my first year :) Trying to get another this year too! #phdchat

@moorejh - @gawbul @qui_oui I was told early in my career that I was travelling too much. I didn't listen. Boy were they wrong! #PhD101 #PhDchat

@londonaesthetik - that's insane. RT @DrSustainable: @TGJBrock @nsriazat Some institutions introducing quotas - 4 paper per year etc.. #phdchat

@Roretto - My supervisor advised me to publish my literature review and methodology chapters. So I'm thinking after the upgrade 2 work on them #phdchat

@moorejh - #PhD101 #PhDchat see http://t.co/f2g3vBXA http://t.co/sRSM6MvW - I like many of these points for building an academic career.

@moorejh - MT @margagual Believe in yourself. Don't be afraid to challenge dogma. Your supervisor has been away from bench for 20 yrs #PhDchat #PhD101

@JaneDavis13 - @lizith @EmmaBurnettx sorry to shout #phdchat

@ianrobsons - Sketched out a helpful note on a three stage analysis for narrative data based on a tiny scribble on a post-it! #phdchat #gowithit

@moorejh - love the stick figures #phd101 #phdchat RT @Protohedgehog @DNLee5: The PhDs Guide to Academic Conferences http://t.co/A4Jwobs6

@DrSustainable - Anyone have quota for number of publications/year? #phdchat #acwri #academia #research

@LBA_OX12 - How does getting a paper publish fit with not revealing too much of your ideas @ early stage in your research? #phdchat

@DrSustainable - @londonaesthetik To be clear, quota 4 academic staff post PhD.... #phdchat

@lindathestar - Unsure of your topic or ideas? 'Sip sherry in a dark room' #phdadvice #phdchat

@Photonique - Anyone hear from this cold-calling academic publishing house http://t.co/CdwcDs47 ? Downsides of #open-access #scam #PhDchat

@AndrologistUK - @LBA_OX12 good question! #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - brilliant! I will switch to port though! RT @lindathestar: Unsure of your topic or ideas? 'Sip sherry in a dark room' #phdadvice #phdchat

@merry30 - @londonaesthetik I'll join you in a port! @lindathestar #phdchat

@londonaesthetik - Delightful! RT @merry30: @londonaesthetik I'll join you in a port! @lindathestar #phdchat

@CET47 - @klbz it was interesting to try and concisely summarise my research and there was time for questions after it was difficult to do #phdchat

@mitchellfriedmn - @londonaesthetik @nsriazat Thanks! Very exciting; based on my dissertation! #phdchat

@Peter_Tennant - @DrSustainable I'm expected to first-author two and second-author four per year #Acwri #PhDchat #Researcg #Academia

@KL_Wheat - Useful tips in this Prezi "How to Publish a Discoverable Journal Article" http://t.co/8JsqyxW4 via @SAGE_News #phdchat

@Karen_Smits - Reading the last papers for #EGOS2012 after sight seeing in Helsinki :) #phdchat

@ScienceAtheism - to do tonight: analyse 5 more chromosomes and write them in my report #phdchat

@DrSustainable - @Peter_Tennant wow! How do you find that..along with teaching etc? #phdchat #acwri

@HendraAgustian - I'd love to immerse myself in d glorious discovery of #HiggsBoson particle, but my research requires me 2 stay focussed. #PhDchat #PhDadvice

@PeppeGanga - Journals look just for their profit.Some high IF journals care more about fancy & sexy techniques than the real scientific message #phdchat

@ai1sa - via @londonaesthetik poster presenting http://t.co/sVRN55Gp putting abstract on a poster is like putting a haiku on a limerick #phdchat

@PalgraveTheatre - For all those doing a PhD... RT @thesiswhisperer: PHD Comics: 2 Minute Thesis Competition http://t.co/3NoegLB0 #phdchat

@PalgraveLit - For all those doing a PhD... RT @thesiswhisperer: PHD Comics: 2 Minute Thesis Competition http://t.co/aHqEYIqb #phdchat

@DavidCRoberts - Can you help please? Do you know of any recent research on business incubator success / faliure? #phdchat #3EP #Entrepreneurship #

@Lafrenchfille - PI Quotes - 1 "Always think you're stupid" http://t.co/t94RqVbc via @wordpressdotcom #PhD #PhDchat

@DriesDeRoeck - tomorrow's theme song : http://t.co/znmtr4Xm #commission #phdchat

@Peter_Tennant - @DrSustainable I don't really have any teaching, but it's quite tough alongside a PhD! #Acwri #PhDChat #Research #Academia

@DrSustainable - @Peter_Tennant didn't realise that was alongside your PhD! :0 #Academia #Research #phdadvice #phdchat #acwri

@DrSustainable - @Peter_Tennant I turned down PhD scholarship @ncl - glad now! #acwri #phdchat #phdadvice

@Peter_Tennant - @DrSustainable I guess the expectations will change as my PhD progresses, also can use PhD to produce papers (I hope!) #Acwri #PhDChat

@catspyjamasnz - Book Review: How to Write a Lot #SummerReading For #AcWri http://t.co/VeM6pQkW via @zite #phdchat by @laurapasquini

@Peter_Tennant - @DrSustainable It depends on what funding you're on, mine is 'shoestring', hence other committments. #Acwri #PhDChat #Research #Academia

@DrSustainable - @Peter_Tennant Advice from my supervisors was write each chapter of thesis as if standalone paper... #phdadvice #phdchat #acwri

@ai1sa - ooh love magic, now i have a table of figures in the thesis. Now to make them all a little more consistent. #phdchat

@HendraAgustian - @Peter_Tennant @DrSustainable Wow! That's an enormous quota for publications. How do you live up to that? #PhDchat

@filination - Definitely, most are clinically depressed RT @thesiswhisperer isthere a problem with mental health amongst PhD students? #phdchat

@JohnWLamp - More important than what journals look for, what journals to look for. Choose what's best for your research, not by impact factor. #phdchat

@tmontgomeryrn - @AmandaMichelle @judiebbrell my program gives the choice of a traditional dissertation or publishing three research articles. #PhDchat

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.