| 
  • If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

View
 

Critical Writing

Page history last edited by Steve Moss 8 years, 11 months ago

'Moving from descriptive to critical writing'

 

#phdchat tweet log - 10th October 2012

 

@NSRiazat - Welcome to #phdchat - the topic for tonight is 'moving from descriptive to critical writing'. #PhD #highered #academia

@SueFolley - @debbiefuco good luck - how much notice will they give you? #phdchat

@Have_CISA - LinkedIn Events: IT Auditing - Principles and Practices for Executives and Directors http://t.co/7kbdMoBz #Compliance #TempleU #PhdChat

@debbiefuco - @SueFolley He said three weeks after the 23rd... Nothing is ever set in stone, though. #phdchat

@NSRiazat - To kick off today's chat - how do we define the difference between 'critical' writing and 'descriptive' writing? #phdchat

@chasing_ling - @NSRiazat #phdchat I'll be controversial. Critical writing > a.k.a 'shredding'...

@debbiefuco - @SueFolley How is your prep coming along? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Is critical writing that with persuasion and clear arguments? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @chasing_ling ~ haha....why do you say that? :-) #phdchat

@lizith - @NSRiazat I wish I knew! I've been trying to get my head around the difference for past 4 years and still confused! #phdchat

@chasing_ling - #phdchat sometimes I call critical writing 'smashing' or 'shredding' don't mean to be mean but you have to get inside the data somehow...

@Janshs - something that I start work on with my MA students is the idea of developing a 'synthesis' or 'synthetic argument' #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @lizith ~ I think being critical when writing is more than diagreement? More about why one argument is better than the other?? #phdchat

@Janshs - "you have to get inside the data " I like this from @chasing_ling #phdchat it's vital to immerse yourself I think

@NSRiazat - Persuading from reasons and then concluding from reasoning? #phdchat

@debbiefuco - Having trouble with the word persuasion. RT @NSRiazat: Is critical writing that with persuasion and clear arguments? #phdchat

@debbiefuco - Oh, okay. That makes sense. RT @NSRiazat: Persuading from reasons and then concluding from reasoning? #phdchat

@iambuttons - If i ever return to uni to do a phd, it has to be in Finland http://t.co/xu5HG8pN #higherEd #phdchat top hat and sword. #orsm

@NSRiazat - @debbiefuco ~ Easier said than done - struggled to locate arguments from descriptive writing. #phdchat

@debbiefuco - @NSRiazat I was thinking of persuasion from the arm twisting point-of-view...jaded by the political climate, here. #phdchat

@SueFolley - @debbiefuco not too bad thanks :) - hard to know on what to concentrate my efforts though :) #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - Descriptive writing is reporting what other people say critical writing is having an opinion on it #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Is being critical looking for similarities and differences in arguments between your work and that of other authors in the field? #phdchat

@tressiemcphd - Paper comments: An "A" with "valiant effort!" written beside it. Discuss. #gradschool #phdchat

@mkooleady - @NSRiazat @lizith #phdchat I think that being critical has as much to do with seeing connections as disconnections.

@SueFolley - critical writing is also being able to highlight the strengths and weaknesses in an argument someone is making #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @mkooleady ~ agreed. Also think I need to explore the weaknesses in some of my arguments more carefully. #phdchat

@erica_r_e_lewis - .@katmduffy #phdchat I'm new here - started my phd this week, but @thesiswhisperer and associated website have been great

@debbiefuco - based on your findings? RT @Judiebbrell: Descriptive writing=reporting; critical writing=opinion #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @mkooleady ~ need to focus on what is necessary in the writing and what is sufficient to bring word count down. #phdchat

@mkooleady - @NSRiazat #phdchat And issues of the underlying philosophical commensurability.

@RonaldArendse - "@SueFolley: critical writing is also being able to highlight the strengths and weaknesses in an argument someone is making #phdchat"

@SueFolley - @erica_r_e_lewis welcome!! :) Good luck with your phd :)) #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @SueFolley ~ agreed. Also like looking for different explanations to phenomena from other people's work. Different from my own. #phdchat

@ErinHillforts - @NSRiazat Maybe that's the start of it, but then you have to be able to weigh up the pros & cons of those arguements to be critical #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Assessing the strength of arguments made. #phdchat

@lizith - @erica_r_e_lewis welcome - good to have you on board @katmduffy @thesiswhisperer #phdchat

@mkooleady - @NSRiazat OMG. I'm so tired of working to word limits! #phdchat

@SueFolley - @NSRiazat exactly - looking at a point from a different perspective :) #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @mkooleady ~ me too - but if I didn't work to word limit I might end up writing equivalent of three theses in one document. :-) #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @ErinHillforts - agreed - some arguments are more justified than others depending on the context of the work. #phdchat

@mkooleady - @SueFolley @nsriazat #phdchat Good point. Different perspectives are rich sources of insight.

@NSRiazat - Did anyone have specific input in being crtiical as part of their course or is this a skill we develop ourselves? #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Have spent a lot of time going round in circles with my arguments. Mindmapping concepts and arguments/evidence helped. #phdchat

@JaneDavis13 - @NSRiazat: @mkooleady ~ agreed. Also think I need to explore the weaknesses in some of my arguments more carefully. #phdchat <- good point

@Judiebbrell - @NSRiazat been to workshop in critical thinking and writing but not alway able to put it into practice in writing #phdchat

@mkooleady - @NSRiazat #phdchat I must admit that my Findings chapter turned out much better after having cut 30% of the words. More concise.

@SueFolley - @NSRiazat I wish we did - as I think it is a difficult skill to develop :) #phdchat

@ai1sa - some critical thinking approaches are imbedded in philosophical underpinnings of method; eg activity theory, point is empowerment #phdchat

@ruthmassierose - @SueFolley: @NSRiazat I wish we did - as I think it is a difficult skill to develop :) #phdchat <- I agree

@SueFolley - @erica_r_e_lewis definitely - doing a phd can be isolating - nice to surround yourself with people who know how you feel #phdchat

@SueFolley - @ruthmassierose and everyone here on #phdchat are lovely and supportive :)

@mkooleady - @NSRiazat #phdchat No. Nothing specific in courses. I think it happens with critique from peers, instructors, and journal/conference reviews

@explorstyle - #phdchat Maybe critical writing involves the confidence to connect literature to our own work; descriptive writing allows us to hang back.

@lizith - @ai1sa I sometimes wish I had found myself a clear method, rather than spending too much time convincing sups on merit of method #phdchat

@mkooleady - @ai1sa #phdchat Interesting. Please tell me more . . .

@NSRiazat - @Judiebbrell @mkooleady @SueFolley @ErinHillforts @ruthmassierose ~ think we are left to develop it as we progress through. #phdchat

@ai1sa - Some philosophical underpinnings 100% critical, eg Habermas or Marx or Foucault or feminism= power relations /imbalances to redress #phdchat

@ErinHillforts - Takes a long time to develop & depends on confidence too- is it able to be taught? I struggle & I'm coming up for half way through! #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Wish I had left more time to assess strength of arguments in papers I have read earlier on in writing process. #phdchat

@ErinHillforts - @mkooleady @NSRiazat so do you think conference papers are important for this? Im scared of the criticism-some academics lack tact! #phdchat

@ai1sa - & some dont. ANT = descriptive, but also uncovers relationships, dynamics, points to how things dont have to be the way/s they are #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - @NSRiazat @mkooleady @SueFolley @ErinHillforts @ruthmassierose I agree sometimes it comes easy sometimes it just doesn't! #phdchat

@SueFolley - My supervisor was helpful in pointing out where I had been critical well and where I hadn't -so could compare :) #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Seems (from personal perspective) that as soon as have learnt basics of academic writing - it is time to hand in the thesis.:-) #phdchat

@Janshs - key point MT @NSRiazat Wish I'd left more time to assess strength of arguments in papers I have read earlier on in writing process. #phdchat

@ai1sa - another form of critique/beinng critical is the ability to name where mixed methods clash, or where solo methods might have 'holes' #phdchat

@debbiefuco - Congratulations to @NSRiazat for being mentioned as one of 50 Education Leaders to Follow on Twitter! http://t.co/AHvx25up #phdchat

@lizith - @SueFolley that sounds really helpful! Wish mine would do that! #phdchat

@SueFolley - Being critical is also not taking everything you read at face value - look for evidence of claims made #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @ErinHillforts ~ as long as we believe that feedback is constructive (however delivered) & intended to help us be better academics. #phdchat

@SueFolley - @lizith it was really helpful :) #phdchat

@ai1sa - @SueFolley @lizith mine had to tell me when to pull my head in as my method is less critical more descriptive #phdchat

@Janshs - I really do think you need to write thesis in order to know how to write a thesis #phdchat

@SueFolley - @NSRiazat sounds about right :) #phdchat

@debbiefuco - Like! RT @explorstyle: #phdchat Critical writing = confidence to connect literature to our work; descriptive = allows us to hang back.

@SueFolley - @ai1sa loll - I should have chosen that method then :)) #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - @debbiefuco @SueFolley @NSRiazat congratulations #phdchat

@ruthmassierose - @ErinHillforts I wasn't confident wrt to confs having seen some "academic tact" but found them immensely supportive #phdchat

@lizith - I think there is something abt balance - some of writing is informative, some descriptive and some building argument #phdchat

@debbiefuco - So, true! RT @SueFolley: Being critical is also not taking everything you read at face value - look for evidence of claims made #phdchat

@mkooleady - @ai1sa #phdchat For me, discovering my philosophical position/tendencies gave me a base upon which to examine others. And . . .

@mgto_org - Dailypic: Going in for the Thesis Defense.. http://t.co/bcCp1PAj #phdchat #academia

@debbiefuco - @NSRiazat You SO deserve the accolades! Bravo! #phdchat

@scottcowley - Academic Journals That Could Be Broadway Shows If An Exclamation Point Were Added http://t.co/MNcD3KC4 #phdchat

@strictlykaren - @SueFolley @Janshs reading other thesis from your discipline also helps understand what is expected for phd #phdchat

@SueFolley - @NSRiazat very well deserved! Congrats :)) #phdchat

@SueFolley - @strictlykaren @Janshs yes true - I did that and found it incredibly useful - and made it seem doable as well :) #phdchat

@ErinHillforts - @ruthmassierose Most are supportive, I agree, but some seem to constantly criticize & they have the loudest voices... #phdchat

@mkooleady - @mkooleady @ai1sa #phdchat Also, examining other philos shapes my philosophy . . . Co-construction.

@lizith - @strictlykaren @SueFolley @Janshs but there's a problem when what doing doesn't quite fit discipline or crosses boundaries #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @mkooleady @ai1sa ~ also about critiqueing the argument and not the author themselves. #phdchat

@strictlykaren - @SueFolley @janshs yes, that was turning point for me. I read a few and thought "I CAN do this" #phdchat

@SueFolley - @strictlykaren @janshs yes totally - me too! Up till then I didn't think it was a reality :) #phdchat

@michaelslav - Pls RT #phdchat Meaningful, well-paid, part-time work for PhDs: check out @BrilliantClub. We want researchers to inspire bright pupils!

@ruthmassierose - @strictlykaren:reading other thesis from your discipline also helps understand what is expected #phdchat esp ones with the same supervisor

@mkooleady - @NSRiazat #phdchat Absolutely. I think that when students are new to doctoral studies, they think they must go on the "attack".

@explorstyle - @Janshs @NSRiazat Absolutely! And, paradoxically, that knowledge means that we shouldn't linger too long in the writing phase. #phdchat

@strictlykaren - @lizith @suefolley @janshs true but you can read some examples from each side of the boundary #phdchat

@SueFolley - @NSRiazat @mkooleady @ai1sa yes that is an important point! #phdchat

@nataliematosin - @thesiswhisperer RT Are you a first generation PhD student? Sure am. Proudest day of my parents life = day I graduated from Honours #phdchat

@SueFolley - @thesiswhisperer yes I'm a first generation PhD student. My parents have no academic qualifications, so even a BSc was a big deal #phdchat

@JackieKirkham - @NSRiazat Bingo! ;) #phdchat

@explorstyle - The critical/descriptive distinction breaks down as our own argument emerges because we know what needs to be said in our own text #phdchat

@debbiefuco - Yep. Wonder what the stats are on that? RT @thesiswhisperer: Are you a first generation PhD student? #phdchat http://t.co/n6TrewzB

@lizith - @strictlykaren @suefolley @janshs there is merit obviously in reading other theses, but danger of cloning rather than originality #phdchat

@Judiebbrell - @ruthmassieros very easy to get lost in British library can waste days reading other peoples work instead of writing! #phdchat

@lizith - @strictlykaren @suefolley @janshs when pulling ideas/framework together in unconventional way, more difficult to find helpful model #phdchat

@blueanna - @NSRiazat #phdchat learning to think and read critically is something that I'm having to pick up as I go along.

@strictlykaren - @lizith @suefolley @janshs I wasn't really suggesting cloning, rather more for confidence in how to write, level of critique etc #phdchat

@nataliematosin - Podcast Episode 8: Live #PhDchat with the Thesis Whisperer Inger Mewburn http://t.co/SEB7Hu5g via @litreviewhq

@ai1sa - @mkooleady yes i would agree #phdchat

@explorstyle - @ruthmassierose @strictlykaren Nobody ever writes a novel or a poem or a memoir without reading at least a few examples first! #phdchat

@lizith - @strictlykaren @suefolley @janshs fair enough - I'm over-sensitive abt being made to fit particular sausage skin & not buying it! #phdchat

@ruthmassierose - I agree, the level of critique is difficult as it can stray from descriptive to critical - it's such a tough balance #phdchat

@qui_oui - "The academic migrant experience": yes, things are different for "first in the family" PhDs. http://t.co/bGvGtX6v #HigherEd #PhDchat

@strictlykaren - @lizith oh that's funny, I like that analogy, I may clone that ;) #phdchat

@ai1sa - my stuck point was multiple realities being valid but still having own voice, fortunately other writers give guidance #phdchat

@lizith - @strictlykaren :) maybe that is actually the point about finding our own voice, which may not match the expected model #phdchat

@ai1sa - @strictlykaren @lizith I used my blog for practicing voice- taking the writing of others and following a similar line of argument #phdchat

@strictlykaren - @ai1sa @lizith I'm not very good at blogging regularly enough, must try harder #phdchat

@ai1sa - @lizith good part of crossing disciplines is the scope for post doc writing in multiple directions #phdchat

@ai1sa - @strictlykaren im irregular alos. But i use it especially when stuck and when curiousity piqued #phdchat

@Paully232000 - @strictlykaren @ai1sa @lizith I also must start blogging more, set up an account but never really got it off the ground #phdchat

@lizith - @ai1sa that's true! but it's also finding the right outlets if being less conventional - we are expected to join tribe, not all do #phdchat

@ai1sa - @Paully232000 e b polite in blogging, had the author of an article i attempted to critique respond #phdchat

@mkooleady - @SueFolley #phdchat Did you find ways to help them understand your interest and what the degree means?

@ai1sa - @lizith yes, i chose to join a tribe #phdchat

@Paully232000 - @blueanna @NSRiazat I remember having some critical analysis assignments at MSc level, but mostly has been self-developed #phdchat

@Janshs - @lizith @strictlykaren @SueFolley sorry I wandered off to the tumble dryer for a while there .... all good points re non-conformity #phdchat

@Paully232000 - @ai1sa Was the author pleased with your thoughts? #phdchat

@Janshs - @lizith @strictlykaren @SueFolley whilst still addressing the need to meet requirements! not easy to balance #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @TeachNorthern @SueFolley - good point about not taking arguments literally at face value-looking at vested interest/expertise etc #phdchat

@mkooleady - @ai1sa @lizith #phdchat I'm hoping the tribe will let me join! He he he!

@lizith - @Janshs @strictlykaren @suefolley I suspect the biggest prob with not conforming is finding right examiners #phdchat

@Paully232000 - @NSRiazat @TeachNorthern @SueFolley and then looking for counter-arguments, or other pieces of work that back up first argument #phdchat

@ai1sa - @Paully232000 polite, http://t.co/5RVl6Nks agreed in part, disagreed in others #phdchat

@lizith - @mkooleady @ai1sa I think my problem is I don't really identify with any tribe I've so far encountered - hmmm #phdchat

@Janshs - @lizith certainly #phdchat

@ai1sa - @lizith i would agree, important to have markers who are prepared for difference. Do you get input into this? #phdchat

@Paully232000 - @ai1sa Sure it was useful to be able to discuss your thoughts with the author, not sure how often that would happen #phdchat

@SueFolley - @mkooleady they were supportive really - just didn't fully understand. Explained it was important for future career :) #phdchat

@lizith - @ai1sa been discussing options with sups - biggest issue will be internal examiner - there are interesting options for external #phdchat

@ai1sa - @Paully232000 at conferences possibility- but i'm too in awe, i need more reflective space. #phdchat

@NSRiazat - 8.30pm BST brings us to the end of live #phdchat for this week - thank you all for contributions as always - see you all next week. :-)

@strictlykaren - @lizith do you have any say in who examiners are #phdchat

@NSRiazat - Great to catch up with the #PhD community as always - if there is a topic you would like to see on poll please let me know. #phdchat

@mkooleady - @SueFolley #phdchat Yeah. It seems that others need an explanation that makes it tangible-- some scaffolding.

@ruthmassierose - @NSRiazat thanks for an interesting hour #phdchat

@strictlykaren - @NSRiazat thanks for organising again, and well done on being in top 50 #phdchat

@SueFolley - @mkooleady is it the same for you? :) #phdchat

@lizith - @strictlykaren I've been suggesting names and identifying probs with some suggestions - biggest issue is internal #phdchat

@RitaBusyWoman - A good article always tells a story. #phdchat

@NSRiazat - @ruthmassierose ~ thank you - you're welcome. Hope to catch up with you next week or on #phdchat - have a great week. :-)

@Paully232000 - @NSRiazat Thanks, pity I missed the first 1/2 hr, but can read through it all. Last 1/2 very interesting. Look forward to next one #phdchat

@mkooleady - @lizith #phdchat Oh, yes. Finding examiners would be difficult. Maybe find a middle ground. Must get "done". Fight later!

@lizith - @strictlykaren I'm based in sociology dept, but just not a sociologist, so really need somebody else local who understands my work #phdchat

@strictlykaren - @lizith I think external carries most weight though so it might balance out if you get someone good ext and some1 reasonable int #phdchat

@Paully232000 - @ai1sa #phdchat I think I will be like that at my first conference, but must get over that and talk to the speakers if given the chance.

@NSRiazat - @Paully232000 ~ great to see you on #phdchat - I think it is archived on the #phdchat wiki.

@lizith - @strictlykaren that's what I'm hoping - one of sups is not sociology & she's on case! #phdchat

@pauldoshea - Doing a PhD is a currency of communication between fellow researchers, but it can be a conversation stopper with those who are not! #phdchat

@ai1sa - @RitaBusyWoman i agree, & it stimulates ongoing conversation. good article/thesis /paper enters into a conversation (slow though) #phdchat

@erica_r_e_lewis - @NSRiazat #phdchat - yes thank you for bringing us together. Looking forward to future discussions.

@SueFolley - @NSRiazat thanks for #phdchat tonight - great discussion :) #phdchat

@ai1sa - converse might also be true. A bad thesis/paper etc stops the conversation Here i blog Foucault on critique http://t.co/jdTonPK1 #phdchat

@lizith - @mkooleady I think I would take that line if younger, as it is, this is bit of last shot! Not worried about outcomes though #phdchat

@mkooleady - @pauldoshea #phdchat Good point. But, find something they can relate to. Make it real. Example coming: from a friend. . .

@lizith - time for supper - been good to talk - see you around :) #phdchat

@mkooleady - @pauldoshea #phdchat My friend says: I'm doing an EdD -- I'm like someone who designs learning spaces like Facebook. People get that.

@qui_oui - Feeling like a slob today even though technically I worked on my dissertation all day. It's the whole "not going outside" thing... #phdchat

@mkooleady - @lizith #phdchat I love the way you phrased that! "The final full stop."

@mkooleady - Night everyone! #phdchat

@Galindes - Are Grad students more depressed? Yes - and humanities slightly more than sciences. (Via @ThesisWhisperer). #PhDChat. - http://t.co/gH5nZxwQ

@raulpacheco - #acadjobs #ECRChat #PhDchat #PhDAdvice RT @professor_evy: Anthropology tenure track position at Guelph http://t.co/633oxLBu

@SueFolley - @mkooleady night - nice chatting to you :) #phdchat

@Janshs - good #phdchat rhis eve - thanks to @NSRiazat and all

@raulpacheco - St Anne's College, Oxfordinvites applications for Global Justice Research Fellowships http://t.co/KQMApJDI #PhDChat #PhDAdvice #ECRChat

@cdp_xe - Inviting co-authors (also read the very interesting comments on undergrad co-authors!) http://t.co/eXqW4CIq #phd #phdchat

@NeuroFi - Fantasizing about an art project: "Capturing the different faces of despair" featuring the members of my stats class. #phdchat

@laurapasquini - This article title had me at "Hello" => Going Rogue - Manage Your Career -http://t.co/WVhI7dl1 #phdchat #gradchat #drphd

@MargaretEdits - 5 More Reasons Why All Students Should Be Bloggers http://t.co/TpfoNfY9 #Phdchat #writing

@GradStudentWay - Customize Your #Science #Training: Extra #Skills To Get Attention From #Industry: http://t.co/Ck64tDqF #biotech #phdchat #phdforum #highered

@NazlinBhimani - @NSRiazat You're welcome! Expecting a lot of the MPhil/PhD and MRes students from @IOE_London to follow #phdchat!

@SueFolley - @EmmaBurnettx morning! you missed a good #phdchat - in fact I think it was your suggestion for topic :)))

@EmmaBurnettx - @londonaesthetik @suefolley It did occur to me that I should have waited until I got back to suggest this topic! #badplanning #phdchat

@lynntrinko - Congrats @NSRiazat for being one of 50 Education Leaders to Follow on Twitter! http://t.co/ugRALXGE #phdchat

@SueFolley - @EmmaBurnettx @londonaesthetik yes it was a popular topic - maybe they will add the chat to the wiki so you can catch up #phdchat

@LuxePHD - 10pm. Leaving the office. With a headache. #PhDchat

@m_m_campbell - Depression isn't a personal failing or weakness. Helping grad students & postdocs. http://t.co/qsBltcaN by @VirginiaGewin #phdchat

@DamaraKautz - The two best phrases in graduate school: "free food" and "open bar." #gradchat #phdchat

@PhDForum - @KimMadden01 Wow, how wonderful for you that the end is in sight, you will get there #onedayatatime :-) #phdforum #phdchat

@justinohearn - How should I prepare for the qualified exams? #phdchat http://t.co/ws7xuPHE

@Paully232000 - @NSRiazat great thanks I will have a read of the #phdchat wiki

@EmmaReid01 - Any suggestions for analysing tweets that I have favourited as phd fieldwork? #phdchat

@strictlykaren - Storify from last week's #Acwri on how to avoid losing work/words http://t.co/c0dHoIHx #phdchat

@thetrudz - If you have a PDF of your CV you sent in when applying to a PhD program & don't mind sharing, please tweet! #phdchat #gradchat

@researchwhisper - MT @dr_krystal The human cost of metrics in academia: ECRs at risk. Insightful post by @JennyRohn http://t.co/QTt4UIIf #ecrchat #phdchat

@PetaFreestone - Note to self: You get bored easily. Never again sign up to study one topic for four years. Do some fun new eclectic ugrad thing. #phdchat

@PhDForum - http://t.co/LeD6UChf via @mailandguardian #phdchat #highereducation

 

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.